| PAST CHAMPIONS | |||
| Category | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 |
| Overall | CBS Sports | One Time Fantasy Sports | The Sports Outlaw |
| Quarterback | CBS Sports ESPN |
One Time Fantasy Sports | Fantasy Draft Edge Fantasy Football Whiz NFL Freaks The Sports Outlaw Xtreme Fantasy Football |
| Running Back | Accuscore | Fantasy Mojo | The Football Times |
| Wide Receiver | CBS Sports | CBS Sports | Fantasy Football
Helpers Sport Fanatics Xtreme Fantasy Football |
| Tight End | About Fantasy Football | Fantasy Football Today | The Sports Outlaw |
| Kicker | Accuscore | Mr. Fantasy | Junkyard Jake |
